03.11.13 Embedding Non-Fiction in “The Giver”
Got an email last week from Lindsey Hugoat the consistently high-performing Edward Brooke Charter School
in Boston. Lindsey’s 6th graders have been reading The Giver, which earns her instant glory points for rigorous text selection and for choosing what the gang here at Uncommon thinks is one of the very best works of youth fiction. ( I personally rank it #1
.)
Anyway, Lindsey wrote to share two of her embedded non-fiction texts and the questions she uses to link the fiction to the non-fiction. Not only do these represent really interesting and rigorous choices but it’s so useful to see how an ace teacher plans. Anyway check out Lindsey’s embedded texts here:
I especially like the series of questions comparing decisions on who gets to do what in the German school system and the Community’s school system, as well as the last questionin the dreams article… what do these lines tell us about the setting of The Giver ? (In other words students have to infer that we can’t actually control dreams so The Giver must be science fiction). Also lot’s of meta-attention to how the articlesare structured. Great stuff, Lindsey!
For those of you who haven’t joined us for one of our reading workshops–thanks to everyone who came last week!– here’s a quick primer on embedding. And for those of you who are embedding, what do (or would) you pair with The Giver ?
resources
, Teach Like a Champion; Reading; Embedded Non-fiction
, The Giver
Great! Thanks for sharing this new technique 🙂
The link to the texts is broken. Any hopes of getting it fixed? Thanks!
Thanks for letting us know! We’re working on it.
Thank you!
Fixed! Link is working again.
I have a question,
Were these selections given before or after students read The Giver? My students will be reading the giver in a week or so, and I wanted to do some non fiction pairing, but was not sure if this was done before or after students had read the book.
Thank You!
i think you could use them anywhere. generally in the midst of reading is the best…. we tend to fall back on before or after… i personally like “in the middle”
I need information on what texts are related to the giver, its for a class project. Do you know of any?
I cannot get the linked text to open??